Subscribe



Subscribe by Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner






Get your own free Blogoversary button!

Bookmark TDF!

Follow @tdfangirl!





Speculative Romance, or Where Does SFR Fit?

by multmatsherm @ flickr

by multmatsherm @ flickr

There’s a really fascinating discussion going on in my Paranormal Romance group on GoodReads. Linnea Sinclair asked a very interesting, provocative question: Should science fiction romance be part of the paranormal romance genre?

Wikipedia, that bastion of always-accurate information, says that paranormal romance “blends the real with the fantastic or science fictional. The fantastic elements may be woven into an alternate version of our own world in an urban fantasy involving vampires, demons, and/or werewolves, or they may be more ‘normal’ manifestations of the paranormal—humans with psychic abilities, witches, or ghosts. Time-travel, futuristic, and extraterrestrial romances also fall beneath the paranormal umbrella.”

In my opinion, paranormal is the wrong genre to act as such a blanket. The most common and recognizable characteristics of paranormal romances (PNR) are similar to those in urban fantasy: supernatural creatures, psychic or magic powers, witches, etc. While science fiction romance (SFR) may include psychic powers and strange creatures, I would argue that the futuristic and/or extraterrestrial setting places it outside the realm of PNR. Generally, PNR takes place either in a modern/close-to-modern realistic setting (realistic meaning set in our world or a fictional place either in or very similar to our world) or in a historically accurate setting. For example, Christine Warren’s Novels of the Others are set in modern New York. Teresa Medeiros writes vampire novels set in Regency England. Both of these are considered PNR.

But what about SFR? It can be set in the far future or in the present day, in a distant galaxy or even on Earth, but the defining factor is science. According to wikipedia, science fiction “often involves speculations based on current or future science or technology.” Science fiction romance, as a blended subgenre of SF and romance, therefore also deals with science and technology. While psychic powers are often used and there are strange creatures (aliens, for the most part, and not werewolves), SFR uses these elements in a setting that is distinctly different from most PNR. There is also a third genre that often gets lumped into PNR: fantasy romance, such as C.L. Wilson’s Novels of the Fading Lands. The setting and use of magic in these books are distinctively fantasy, and yet they’re often thought of as paranormals.

Of course, there are always exceptions to any genre rule, and PNR seems to be a very flexible genre. I’ve read PNR that is set in the far future, and even vampires in space. Genres are meant to be blended, right? But in the grand scheme of things, I think that PNR and SFR are different enough to warrant their own distinct subgenres.

So, what can we use as a blanket genre for PNR, SFR, and even fantasy romance? I’d argue for the creation of speculative romance. Speculative fiction, or spec fic, is used as a blanket genre for science fiction, fantasy, and supernatural fiction, so it would make perfect sense to group romances with these elements under a similar title.

What’s your take on the situation?

Advance Review: Kitty Raises Hell by Carrie Vaughn + GIVEAWAY!

Kitty Raises HellBook 6 in the Kitty Norville Series

Preorder: On Amazon.com
Release Date: 24 February 2009

Description: Sometimes what happens in Vegas doesn’t stay in Vegas.

Kitty and Ben flee The City That Never Sleeps, thinking they were finished with the dangers there, but the sadistic cult of lycanthropes and their vampire priestess have laid a curse on Kitty in revenge for her disrupting their rituals. Starting at the next full moon, danger and destruction the form of fire strikes Kitty and the pack of werewolves she’s sworn to protect.

She enlists the help of a group of TV paranormal investigators – one of whom has real psychic abilities – to help her get to the bottom of the curse that’s been laid on her. Rick, the Master vampire of Denver, believes a deeper plot lies behind the curse, and he and Kitty argue about whether or not to accept the help of a professional demon hunter – and vampire – named Roman, who arrives a little too conveniently in the nick of time.

Unable to rely on Rick, and unwilling to accept Roman’s offer of help for a price, Kitty and her band of allies, including Vegas magician Odysseus Grant and Kitty’s own radio audience, mount a trap for the supernatural being behind the curse, a destructive force summoned by the vengeful cult, a supernatural being that none of them ever thought to face.

The Fangirl’s Review: A

This review has the same caveat as my review of Kitty and the Dead Man’s Hand. I haven’t read the first four Kitty Norville books. I’m planning on it, having enjoyed these two, but I just haven’t had time (as is evidenced by the lack of posting around here lately; I’ve been insanely busy with work and school!). So I can’t make a judgment call on this book based on how it fits into the series as a whole.

I really enjoyed this book, more so than I did Kitty and the Dead Man’s Hand. I felt like the plot was more well-developed and depended less on coincidence and randomly appearing characters, and that definitely strengthened the story.

I was a bit wary of a cast-of-thousands when the paranormal investigators of Paradox PI showed up, as I half-expected them to be a side plot that might clutter up the rest of the story, but I was pleasantly surprised when they turned out to be integral to the main plot. The team, consisting of two scientists and one woman with a very interesting secret, come to Denver to do their usual bump-in-the-night investigations and end up staying on to help Kitty with her Very Big Problem: a fiery demon sent by the cult of Tiamat, the vampire-led baddies from the previous book.

The hunt for the demon is nicely creepy; I really like the suspense that builds in those scenes, and Kitty’s wolfish fight-or-flight fear is very believable and effective. I also liked her pack’s dynamics. It’s interesting, that she’s an alpha who rules through friendship rather than intimidation or violence, but I wonder how long she’ll be able to maintain that status quo.

The subplot that most interested me was the one involving Roman, the mysterious vampire who shows up in Denver and offers to get rid of the demon–for a price. And unfortunately, the price is one Rick, Denver’s master vampire, is unwilling to pay. Roman tossed a nice little monkey wrench into the story. Should Kitty trust him? The answer to that is a resounding, “Hell no,” but the more important question is should she work with him anyway? She’s stuck between a rock and a hard place, and I was biting my fingernails, trying to figure out what she should do.

Overall, everything in this book came together very nicely, and I was left feeling like some plot elements or characters came out of the blue in a deus ex machina kind of way. I really enjoyed it, too, and can I just say that it’s very nice to be able to sit down and read a book in one sitting? I’ve been reading a lot of literary theory lately, and it’s so refreshing to be able to sit down and devour a book in three hours without worrying about highlighting and notating important passages. It’s so lovely to be able to just enjoy a book. [happy sigh]

Other Reviews:

And… [drumroll] now for a giveaway!

To celebrate the back-to-back releases of Kitty and the Dead Man’s Hand and Kitty Raises Hell, I’m giving away a complete set of Kitty Norville books!

How To Enter: Comment to this entry and tell me why you want this set of books. Maybe you checked ‘em out of the library and loved ‘em to death. Maybe you haven’t read them at all and are dying to. Just tell me your reason! You must post this first comment to be entered into the contest.

You can gain an additional entry by promoting this giveway. Comment with a link to wherever you’ve pimped it out (in your blog, on twitter, on a message board, etc) AFTER you’ve commented with your reason, and get another entry! Aaand you can get one more entry by following my blog! Add The Discriminating Fangirl to your blogroll or your favorite reader, then comment to let me know that you’ve done it.

Contest Info: Each person is allowed three entries total, following the instructions above. Anyone trying to sneak more entries will be disqualified. Only residents of the U.S. and Canada are eligible, and the books cannot be shipped to P.O. box addresses (publisher’s rules). The contest will run until 10:00p.m. Central time on Friday, February 13, 2009 (appropriate, no?). The winner will be notified by email on Saturday, February 14, 2009 and must respond to that email by 10:00p.m. on Monday, February 16, 2009 or another winner will be chosen. So, be sure you enter a valid email address when you post your comments!

Free Neil Gaiman Audiobook!

You can download a completely free audiobook version of Neil Gaiman’s short story “A Study in Emerald” from Audible.com. This is an amazing story, a blend of Holmesian mystery and Cthulhu Mythos. Neil read it aloud when I saw him in Washington D.C. a couple of years ago. Check it out!

3 Urban Fantasy Reviews

Midnight's DaughterMidnight’s Daughter by Karen Chance
The first book in the Dorina Basarab series, a spin-off of Chance’s Cassandra Palmer series.

Buy It Now: On Amazon.com

Description: Dorina Basarab is a dhampir—half-human, half-vampire. Unlike most dhampirs, though, Dory has managed to maintain her sanity. Now Dory’s vampire father has come to her for help— again. Her Uncle Dracula (yes, the Dracula), cruelest among vampires, has escaped his prison. And her father wants Dory to work with gorgeous master vampire Louis-Cesare to put him back there.

Although Dory prefers to work alone, Dracula is the only thing that truly scares her—and when she has to face him, she’ll take all the help she can get… (from amazon.com)

The Fangirl’s Review: B+

I enjoyed this book, but I have to say, I like the Cassie Palmer books better. This series is a spin-off of the Cassie series, in that it features characters from Cassie’s stories, such as Mircea (rowr) and Louis-Cesare. Some minor characters appear, too, though briefly (I absolutely love the idea of Kit Marlowe as a vampire), and a couple of new ones are introduced, such as Mircea and Dracula’s slightly nutty brother, Radu. Claire and Heidar, two characters featured in Chance’s short story contribution to On the Prowl, also appear. Lots of characters, right? Kind of confusing, right? It would probably help to have read the Cassie Palmer series as well as the short story so you’ll get all of the background for Dorina’s story.

It took a while for me to like the main character, Dory. She’s rude, abrasive, and runs on a hair-trigger temper, and while I did come to like her, for quite a while I found myself wishing she’d shut up with the snarky retorts. But Chance pulls the ace out of her sleeve late in the book and develops Dory into a much more complex and sympathetic character than I had expected.

The plot itself–Dory’s father Mircea charges her and Louis-Cesare with recapturing Dracula–it engaging, and I spent a good part of the book wishing Louis-Cesare would hurry up and get over his aversion to dhampirs so he and Dory could get it on, heh. The interaction with the Fey was also pretty interesting, though it sometimes felt like Chance was trying to cram too much into the story. I did like it, though, and will probably pick up the next book in the series when it comes out.

The Devil's DueThe Devil’s Due by Jenna Black
The third book in the Morgan Kingsley series.

Buy It Now: On Amazon.com

Description:
Trust me or die…That’s the choice Morgan Kingsley, exorcist, is given by the gorgeous rogue demon who’s gotten inside her. The truth is, Morgan has dozens of reasons not to trust anyone, from the violence that torched her house and killed her father to a love life that’s left her questioning her relationship with her erstwhile boyfriend, Brian. But Lugh, a king among demons, won’t take no for an answer. He’s prying into her body, her mind, even her sex life. And he’s just pulled Morgan into a power struggle that could have devastating consequences for both the human and demon worlds.

But Morgan still has a job to do: investigating the highly bizarre possession of the son of a wealthy Philadelphia couple. That hunt leads Morgan into a realm of sexual depravity, then a terrifying kidnapping.… Now a woman who makes her living prying demons from their hosts finds her day job colliding with the night: a darkness that is attracting demons of the damnedest sort, including the one who’s about to demand his ultimate due.… (from amazon.com)

The Fangirl’s Review: B+

This is another strong entry in the Morgan Kingsley series. The reason I give this a B+ instead of an A is simply because the story isn’t quite as engaging as the other two in the series. This story feels more like it’s building up the next book in the series, and while it stands on its own well enough, I was left wondering what’s going to come next, and not necessarily in that nail-biting, anticipatory kind of way. I enjoyed it, but it didn’t stick in my mind the way I’d have liked it to.

There were a couple of sexy scenes; Morgan’s lawyer boyfriend Brian is still hanging on, and thankfully he’s becoming more interesting now that he’s entered a morally grey area instead of being so black-and-white, wrong-and-right. I’m not a fan of boy scout characters, and I’m starting to like Brian more now that he’s abandoning that mantle. I’m also growing to like Adam more and more; he’s still a bit of a dick, but he and Morgan are both showing more empathy toward each other, which is a very nice step. Morgan herself is still stubbornly resisting her own resident demon, Lugh, but it was kind of cool to see how Morgan is growing and learning how to let Lugh take control without freaking out.

I’m definitely going to keep reading this series, but this book felt like a bit of a rest stop on the way to a much bigger story.

Pleasure UnboundPleasure Unbound by Larissa Ione

Buy It Now: On Amazon.com

Description: In a place where ecstasy can cost you your life . . .

She’s a demon-slayer who hungers for sensual pleasure-but fears it will always be denied her. Until Tayla Mancuso lands in a hospital run by demons in disguise, and the head doctor, Eidolon, makes her body burn with unslakable desire. But to prove her ultimate loyalty to her peers, she must betray the surgeon who saved her life.

Two lovers will dare to risk all.

Eidolon cannot resist this fiery, dangerous woman who fills him with both rage and passion. Not only is she his avowed enemy, but she could very well be the hunter who has been preying upon his people. Torn between his need for the truth and his quest to find his perfect mate before a horrific transformation claims him forever, Eidolon will dare the unthinkable-and let Tayla possess him, body and soul…

The Fangirl’s Review: A+

This book has been sitting in my to be read pile for a while now, and now I’m finding myself wishing I’d read it sooner. Holy cow, this is hot. Smoking hot. Panty-scorching hot.

Both leads are badasses, but it was kind of cool to have the usual fighter/healer stereotype reversed; Eidolon is the demon doctor and Tayla is the slayer. So often the female characters get stuck as the nurturers (Ladies, ever tried to get into a new Dungeons & Dragons group and get stuck playing the cleric? Yeah, me too.), so it was refreshing for Eidolon to be the one with the desire to heal.

Tayla has had a hard life. A child of rape, she was born to a drug-addicted mother and spent her childhood and adolescence either on the streets or being shunted from foster home to foster home. She was taken in by the Aegis, a group of fighters determined to destroy demons, and she bought into their doctrine hook, line, and sinker. Eidolon in a Seminus demon, an incubus who is near his final maturation phase after which he’ll turn into a ravening beast, obsessed with impregnating as many females as possible. He’s holding on by his fingernails, though, because he doesn’t want that; he wants to stay himself and stay with the hospital that he created to take care of his fellow demons.

They meet when Tayla is brought into his hospital, and he immediately realizes that all is not what it seems with the Aegis slayer. I won’t say any more, as I don’t want to spoil the book, but I had a hell of a good time reading this book. The mystery was twisty enough to keep me guessing, the growing relationship between Tayla and Eidolon was incredibly hot–I adore love-hate relationships, and Ione writes them very well.

The only complaint I have is that it was kind of difficult to sympathize with Tayla’s beliefs about demons, as the reader is introduced to Eidolon first. But overall, I thought this was an outstanding book, and I really hope the second book in the Demonica series is just as good.

Reading, reading, reading!

I go on vacation and I come back with a dozen new books. That’s my M.O.

And since I’ve been doing a lot of traveling, I’ve also been doing a lot of reading. So far this year, I’ve finished Karen Chance’s Midnight’s Daughter, Jenna Black’s The Devil’s Due, and Larissa Ione’s Pleasure Unbound, reviews of all of which will be posted today. I’m currently reading the first Hellboy compilation, Seed of Destruction. It’s nice to read for pleasure. Wish I could quit school and read full time. ;)

Those reviews will be up shortly. Hope you’re having a good day!