Review: The Mysterious Lady Law by Robert Appleton

February 24, 2011 Books, Reading, Reviews 0 ★★★½


The Mysterious Lady Law is a quick and entertaining read, placing a traditional mystery in a steampunk setting. As fair warning, it clocks in around 31,000 words, making it a novella as opposed to a full-length novel, so if you’re reading it expecting a novel, you’ll run into problems that really aren’t problems considering that this book is not a novel. Everything about it is speedy, from the introduction to the mystery set up to the conclusion. I finished it in a couple of hours, and keeping in mind that I was reading a novella, I enjoyed it.

The mystery itself is fairly simple, but the steampunk setting adds a nice twist to what could have been a fairly typical Sherlock Holmesian whodunit. After her sister’s brutal murder, Julia Bairstow finds herself the surprised recipient of the services of Lady Law, even though her new friend (and possible beau) Constable Grant doesn’t trust the famous detective. I especially like that the sleuthing wasn’t left up to Lady Law, and we actually rarely see her. It’s an unusual choice for the title character to not be the point of view character, but I liked it. It made her more mysterious, and it gave Julia more of a platform to shine.

The mystery is pretty lightweight, and I figured out the “who” pretty well beforehand. What surprised me was the “how.” As I mentioned, the steampunk setting plays heavily into the mystery’s solution, and it was nice to see steampunk tech as more than set dressing.

If you’re looking for an easy, fun read with some nice steampunk elements, give The Mysterious Lady Law a try.

Reviews Elsewhere
Night Owl Sci-Fi
Literary Coldcuts on Toasty Buns
Novel Reaction
Reading the Paranormal
Mel’s Random Reviews